Instant Regrets Vs Smart Picks
Marketing departments convince you that certain sedans are automotive masterpieces. Reality often tells an entirely different story. Behind the glossy brochures and celebrity endorsements lie cars that simply don't meet expectations, let alone exceed them. So, here are 10 overhyped sedans and 10 that truly deserve your attention instead.
1. Tesla Model S Plaid
When Tesla promised a 200 mph top speed for their flagship sedan, they forgot to mention it only hits 162 mph in reality. The Model S Plaid delivers blistering 0–60 times of 2.1 seconds, but that party trick comes with a $130,000 price tag.
2. BMW M5 (V10 Generation)
BMW's decision to adapt its Formula 1 V10 engine for the E60 M5 created an incredible-sounding machine. It serves its drivers genuine thrills at 8,000 rpm. However, this engineering marvel brings along substantial maintenance challenges that tend to impact ownership costs.
skinnylawyer from Los Angeles, California, USA on Wikimedia
3. Nissan Altima
Multiple class-action lawsuits highlight the Altima's weakness: its CVT transmission system, which has plagued owners since 2007. The transmission commonly experiences shuddering, whining noises, and complete failure, typically around 100,000 miles of normal driving. Overheating issues can also cause the system to enter limp mode.
4. Mercedes-Benz W220 S55 AMG
While this car looks imposing and possesses a supercharged V8 with good performance, it suffers from widespread reliability issues that have tarnished its reputation. The W220 generation S-Class emerged during Mercedes-Benz's cost-cutting era, when accountants held more influence than engineers over production decisions.
5. Buick LaCrosse
Buick LaCrosse attempted to compete with German premium brands but consistently fell short in key areas. Besides, the interior materials relied heavily on hard plastics. Brake light switch malfunctions and persistent clunking noises from the steering column have also been reported.
6. Infiniti Q50
This car’s electronic steering system delivers virtually no feedback, rendering it challenging to gauge road conditions or execute precise maneuvers confidently. Infiniti's implementation of drive-by-wire steering technology in the Q50 gave rise to a massive disconnect between driver and road that undermines the driving experience.
7. Cadillac CTS-V
Depreciation rates for American performance sedans are particularly steep, with CTS-V models losing value much faster than European competitors. Maintenance costs rival those of exotic supercars, with magnetic dampers costing $3,000 per corner to replace and supercharger rebuilds requiring substantial investment.
8. Audi A8
While industry sources rate the 2025 A8’s reliability as average or slightly above average, many owners report persistent and expensive problems. These include issues linked with electronics, the cooling system, and power accessories. Some drivers have even reported their A8s spending months at dealerships for repairs.
9. Acura TLX
Honda's attempt to develop a sport sedan using Accord underpinnings resulted in a vehicle that promises more than it gives. Previous versions featured a dual-clutch transmission that exhibited jerky behavior and hesitation during normal driving conditions. Although reliable, the V6 engine lacks the expected refinement.
10. Chevrolet Malibu
Throughout its recent generations, the well-known Malibu struggled to establish a clear identity or competitive advantage over established rivals. General Motors announced the Malibu's discontinuation for 2025, ending a run that never quite found its footing in the competitive midsize sedan market.
Now that we've covered the sedans that do not appeal to car enthusiasts, let's explore the ones that are actually worth considering.
1. Honda Accord
Car and Driver has named the Accord to their 10Best list an unprecedented 37 times. Well, the 2025 model continues this winning streak with a perfect blend of practicality and refinement. Here, you get exceptional value through its spacious cabin and responsive turbocharged engine.
2. Toyota Camry
The 2025 Camry represents Toyota's commitment to reliability, going hybrid-only with a stunning 48 mpg overall fuel economy that puts money back in your pocket every time you fill up. With standard all-wheel drive available across all trims, the Camry now offers year-round confidence.
3. Honda Civic
Kelley Blue Book named it their Compact Car Best Buy for 2025, praising its exceptional resale value that outperforms competitors. The interior feels more upscale than its cost suggests. Also, the new hybrid option generates 200 horsepower with decent fuel economy.
4. Hyundai Elantra
At $22,065, the Elantra proves that budget-conscious doesn't mean budget-quality. This compact sedan has good quality features and refinement, along with a comprehensive 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty. Annual maintenance costs average around $452, which buyers feel is worth it.
5. Genesis G90
Genesis asks a simple question. Why pay Mercedes S-Class prices when you can get the same luxury experience for less? The G90 delivers genuine flagship refinement through massaging seats, whisper-quiet cabins, and innovative technology. Every detail showcases thoughtful engineering, including the soft-close doors.
6. Kia K5
Car and Driver named this beast an Editors' Choice winner, recognizing how Kia changed the former Optima into something truly exciting to look at and drive. The 2025 model brings 191 horsepower, but the real story is the GT variant with 290 horsepower.
7. Mazda3 Sedan (2025)
Undoubtedly, the Mazda3 stands out for its fun-to-drive character and refined handling. It’s enjoyable in city driving and winding roads, with steering and suspension tuning that provide excellent feedback and control. It is known for its premium interior craftsmanship and Human-Machine Interface.
8. Audi A4
Quattro all-wheel drive gives the A4 year-round confidence, especially in challenging weather conditions. The interior personifies German attention to detail through precise build quality, premium materials, and technology integration. Audi's turbocharged four-cylinder engine promises strong acceleration while maintaining respectable fuel economy.
9. Toyota Corolla
Reliability isn't glamorous, but it's valuable when you need dependable transportation that won't drain your bank account. The Corolla has spent decades perfecting the formula for worry-free ownership. As per reports, its hybrid variant can exceed 50 mpg in real-world driving.
10. Nissan Sentra
The 2025 model includes two years of complimentary maintenance, adding even more value to an already good package. It comes with comfortable front seats, including Nissan's Zero Gravity seats, which are spacious and supportive. RepairPal gives it a strong 4.0 out of 5 reliability rating.
